| No | Date | Player | Opponent |
| 1 | Jenkyns, Ceaser | Notts County | |
| 2 | Stafford, Harry | Liverpool | |
| 3 | Downie, Alex | Blackpool | |
| 4 | Griffiths, William | Bradford City | |
| 5 | Turnbull, Sandy | Manchester City | |
| 6 | Meredith, Billy | Brighton | |
| 7 | Turnbull, Jimmy | Aston Villa | |
| 8 | Turnbull, Jimmy | Sheffield United | |
| 9 | West, Enoch | Aston Villa | |
| 10 | Hamill, Michael | Aston Villa | |
| 11 | Hanson, James | Aston Villa | |
| 12 | Moore, Charlie | Leicester City | |
| 13 | Frame, Thomas | Port Vale | |
| 14 | Cockburn, Henry | Manchester City | |
| 15 | Chilton, Allenby | Manchester City | |
| 16 | Pearson, Mark | Burnley | |
| 17 | Herd, David | Willem II | |
| 18 | Law, Denis | Aston Villa | |
| 19 | Crerand, Pat | Burnley | |
| 20 | Law, Denis | Blackpool | |
| 21 | Crerand, Pat | Ferenvaros | |
| 22 | Gregg, Harry | Blackburn Rovers | |
| 23 | Crerand, Pat | Partizan Belgrade | |
| 24 | Law, Denis | Arsenal | |
| 25 | Kidd, Brian | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| 26 | Stiles, Nobby | Estudiantes De La Plata | |
| 27 | Best, George | Estudiantes De La Plata | |
| 28 | Fitzpatrick, John | AC Milan | |
| 29 | Crerand, Pat | Blackpool | |
| 30 | Best, George | Chelsea | |
| 31 | Dunne, Tony | Wolverhampton Wanderers | |
| 32 | Holton, Jim | Newcastle United | |
| 33 | Macari, Lou | Manchester City | |
| 34 | McIlroy, Sammy | Bristol City | |
| 35 | Greenhoff, Brian | Carlisle United | |
| 36 | McQueen, Gordon | Stockport County | |
| 37 | McIlroy, Sammy | Nottingham Forest | |
| 38 | Grimes, Ashley | West Ham United | |
| 39 | Moses, Remi | Arsenal | |
| 40 | Hughes, Mark | Sunderland | |
| 41 | Moran, Kevin | Everton | |
| 42 | Hogg, Graeme | Chelsea | |
| 43 | Robson, Bryan | Sunderland | |
| 44 | O'Brien, Liam | Southampton | |
| 45 | Gibson, Colin | Liverpool | |
| 46 | Bruce, Steve | Luton Town | |
| 47 | Bruce, Steve | Sunderland | |
| 48 | Hughes, Mark | Liverpool | |
| 49 | Hughes, Mark | Torpedo Moscow | |
| 50 | Cantona, Eric | Galatasaray | |
| 51 | Hughes, Mark | Sheffield United | |
| 52 | Schmeichel, Peter | Charlton Athletic | |
| 53 | Cantona, Eric | Swindon Town | |
| 54 | Cantona, Eric | Arsenal | |
| 55 | Kanchelskis, Andrei | Aston Villa | |
| 56 | Parker, Paul | Queens Park Rangers | |
| 57 | Ince, Paul | Gothenburg | |
| 58 | Hughes, Mark | Arsenal | |
| 59 | Cantona, Eric | Crystal Palace | |
| 60 | Keane, Roy | Crystal Palace | |
| 61 | Keane, Roy | Blackburn Rovers | |
| 62 | McGibbon, Pat | York City | |
| 63 | Keane, Roy | Middlesbrough | |
| 64 | Butt, Nicky | West Ham United | |
| 65 | Keane, Roy | Southampton | |
| 66 | Pallister, Gary | Bolton Wanderers | |
| 67 | Solskjaer, Ole-Gunnar | Newcastle United | |
| 68 | Butt, Nicky | Barcelona | |
| 69 | Butt, Nicky | Arsenal | |
| 70 | Neville, Gary | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| 71 | Scholes, Paul | Chelsea | |
| 72 | Keane, Roy | Arsenal | |
| 73 | Irwin, Denis | Liverpool | |
| 74 | Cole, Andrew | Liverpool | |
| 75 | Butt, Nicky | Chelsea | |
| 76 | Beckham, David | Rayos Del Nexaca | |
| 77 | Keane, Roy | Newcastle United | |
| 78 | Butt, Nicky | Watford | |
| 79 | Keane, Roy | Chelsea | |
| 80 | van der Gouw, Raimond | Watford | |
| 81 | Yorke, Dwight | Sunderland | |
| 82 | Chadwick, Luke | Liverpool | |
| 83 | Cole, Andrew | Sunderland | |
| 84 | Keane, Roy | Manchester City | |
| 85 | Keane, Roy | Newcastle United | |
| 86 | Keane, Roy | Sunderland | |
| 87 | Fletcher, Darren | Middlesbrough | |
| 88 | Neville, Gary | Manchester City | |
| 89 | Keane, Roy | Porto | |
| 90 | Ronaldo, Cristiano | Aston Villa | |
| 91 | Fletcher, Darren | Aston Villa | |
| 92 | Smith, Alan | Manchester City | |
| 93 | Brown, Wesley | Liverpool | |
| 94 | Silvestre, Mikael | Arsenal | |
| 95 | Neville, Gary | Everton | |
| 96 | Scholes, Paul | Everton | |
| 97 | Rooney, Wayne | Villarreal | |
| 98 | Scholes, Paul | Lille | |
| 99 | Ronaldo, Cristiano | Manchester City | |
| 100 | Ferdinand, Rio | Blackburn Rovers | |
| 101 | Scholes, Paul | Liverpool | |
| 102 | Scholes, Paul | Roma | |
| 103 | Ronaldo, Cristiano | Portsmouth | |
| 104 | Kuszczak, Tomasz | Portsmouth | |
| 105 | Nani, Luis | West Ham United | |
| 106 | Scholes, Paul | Zenit Saint Petersburg | |
| 107 | Vidic, Nemanja | Liverpool | |
| 108 | Ronaldo, Cristiano | Manchester City | |
| 109 | Vidic, Nemanja | Ldu Quito | |
| 110 | Vidic, Nemanja | Liverpool | |
| 111 | Scholes, Paul | Fulham | |
| 112 | Rooney, Wayne | Fulham | |
| 113 | Fletcher, Darren | Arsenal | |
| 114 | Scholes, Paul | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| 115 | da Silva, Fabio | Wolverhampton Wanderers | |
| 116 | Vidic, Nemanja | Liverpool | |
| 117 | Neville, Gary | Barnsley | |
| 118 | Fletcher, Darren | Birmingham City | |
| 119 | Nani, Luis | Aston Villa | |
| 120 | Carrick, Michael | AC Milan | |
| 121 | da Silva, Rafael | Bayern Munich | |
| 122 | da Silva, Rafael | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| 123 | Vidic, Nemanja | Chelsea | |
| 124 | Evans, Jonny | Bolton Wanderers | |
| 125 | Scholes, Paul | Manchester City | |
| 126 | Vidic, Nemanja | Otelul Galati | |
| 127 | Evans, Jonny | Manchester City | |
| 128 | Nani, Luis | Real Madrid | |
| 129 | da Silva, Rafael | Chelsea | |
| 130 | Fellaini, Marouane | Real Sociedad | |
| 131 | Valencia, Antonio | Hull City | |
| 132 | da Silva, Fabio | Swansea City | |
| 133 | Vidic, Nemanja | Chelsea | |
| 134 | Vidic, Nemanja | Liverpool | |
| 135 | Blackett, Tyler | Leicester City | |
| 136 | Rooney, Wayne | West Ham United | |
| 137 | Smalling, Chris | Manchester City | |
| 138 | Shaw, Luke | West Ham United | |
| 139 | Di Maria, Angel | Arsenal | |
| 140 | Fellaini, Marouane | Hull City | |
| 141 | Mata, Juan | West Bromwich Albion | |
| 142 | Smalling, Chris | Crystal Palace | |
| 143 | Herrera, Ander | Burnley | |
| 144 | Bailly, Eric | Saint Etienne | |
| 145 | Herrera, Ander | Chelsea | |
| 146 | Fellaini, Marouane | Manchester City | |
| 147 | Bailly, Eric | Celta Vigo | |
| 148 | Pogba, Paul | Arsenal | |
| 149 | Rashford, Marcus | Burnley | |
| 150 | Matic, Nemanja | Watford | |
| 151 | Romero, Sergio | Derby County | |
| 152 | Bailly, Eric | Bournemouth | |
| 153 | Pogba, Paul | Paris Saint Germain | |
| 154 | Young, Ashley | Wolverhampton Wanderers | |
| 155 | Matic, Nemanja | Manchester City | |
| 156 | Martial, Anthony | Tottenham Hotspur | |
| 157 | Rodrigues, Fredico "Fred" | Paris Saint Germain | |
| 158 | Wan-Bissaka, Aaron | Young Boys | |
| 159 | Pogba, Paul | Liverpool | |
| 160 | Maguire, Harry | Watford | |
| 161 | Casemiro, Carlos | Crystal Palace | |
| 162 | Casemiro, Carlos | Southampton | |
| 163 | Casemiro, Carlos | Galatasaray | |
| 164 | Rashford, Marcus | Copenhagen | |
| 165 | Dalot, Diogo | Liverpool | |
| 166 | Diallo, Amad | Liverpool |